Just a thought that came to me yesterday evening...

Question:
Who did you prefer?

Choices:
Becca Dean
Mandy Hutchinson

 

i voted becca but its kinda hard to choose cos they were both good; i think they were good for each other to have as best friends. they helped each other through the good and the bad times

They both whined to much, but i said Mandy just because

Becca

mandy.
i love mandy but i also like becca

definatley Mandy i didnt like Becca that much in the end

I prefered becca dean. mandy got on my nerves with her whining lol

I liked Mandy. I liked Becca when I first started watching Hollyoaks. But then she married Jake and had an affair with Justin and moaned constantly even though, lets face it, she got herself into the mess she was in. So I chose Mandy.

Becca..i liked mandy but she kinda got on my nerves sumtimes

#7 of the obsessed with hollyoaks club
#11 of the kress army
#6 of the kris fisher rules club

Becca! Mandy seemed too full of herself

Mandy, just purely for her dress sense! Loved seeing what she was wearing! x

I voted for Becca because i personally think Becca has a much nice personality. I loved Mandy but not to the same extent and i found Mandy quite selfish because when Becca really needed her she wasn't there, and becca had always be there for her even when she was upset and had problems herself.

i really like both of them i didnt want any of them 2 leave its borin without them.

quote:

Originally posted by millystarshine:
I voted for Becca because i personally think Becca has a much nice personality. I loved Mandy but not to the same extent and i found Mandy quite selfish because when Becca really needed her she wasn't there, and becca had always be there for her even when she was upset and had problems herself.

totally agree with you there. becca stood by her mate and was there for her when grace died; i mean she didnt even want to tell her about been pregnant because ofmandys own problems; but she wasnt there when becca really needed her. i think i kinda agreed with wot nancy said at becca's funeral about mandy not been a good mate and she didnt deserve a mate like becca

I prefer Mandy although they've both done stuff that i've disagreed with:

Becca: The whole Justin thing resulted - although indirectly - to her death, And she was much better off with Jake!

Mandy: Going behind Tony's back with Dom! How could she?! Breaking up one's thing but then doing the dirty with her brother is just..wrong!

Becca was a good friend to Mandy? When Mandy saw Becca was upset after Steph having a go at her, Mandy stayed with her. After Mandy had stayed with her all she did was moan and mope about, then the icing on the cake was when uttered "If it wasn't for this baby.." to Mandy.

Why should Mandy have stayed around when Becca was constantly moaning about her self-inflicted problem. Even after Grace died, Becca still managed to steer most convos with Mandy around to her again.

mandy, allthough i like both of them

I liked both of them, but i preferred Mandy! Becca wasn't as good as she was!

Mandy because she was in it for 10 years and nearly always had gripping storylines

However I only liked her up until about 2003. Her relationship with Tony really messed up her character