what do you think the best buy and the worst buy of the transfer market so far and why?
it can be for any club.

duff - what a cheap buy im a liverpool fan and when i heard he went for 5 mill i was so shocked. he is worth at least double that

martins - worst summer signing personally . i say this because he reminds me of cisse about how he has pace and a lot of it but not to sure of his finishing . if u disagree tell me

so BEST and WORST summer signings so far.

I like martins , he is much better than cisse.

Best - Ballack , free transfer which was great and when he starts to play well he will show u how poor lampard really is.

Worst - Transfer window aint closed yet so will tell u then

Best- Kevin McNaughton. I've seen him a few times this season playing for us, and he's got Premiership class all over him

Worst- Martins. A Nigerian striker, need I say anymore?

Best- on perforances so far, maybe Kanu, but i would say overall Andrey Shevchencko


Worse- after sundays performance, maybe Ooijer

Best- Hasselbaink, still gutted Boro didnt hold onto him.

Worst- Arca

I would like to change my choice.

Best - Tevez and Mascherano.

Worst - Yorke to sunderland ( dont c it working fo him there )

Yes Yorkey will be bored after one night out in Sunderland the totty is poor.

Best Shevchenko

Worst Carlton Cole to West Ham just before they signed Tevez.

best - duff .

worst (for the dale anyway) - ricky lambert to bristol rovers for 200 000 .

now the best signings of the summer is tevez and mascerano for west ham sorry to say and i reckon west ham could finish top 5 thank god weve alredy played them

I think my worse is now- Oliver Bernard!

duff great player bargain being a toon fan. for the pool bellamy still respect him great player will be dangerous this year with his pace up front and the 10 foot bean pole up with him.

worst signings

chelsea ballack dont rate him at all done nothing in the world cup he wouldnt run for the ball nothing so think thats a bad one. martins for the toon is a desperate signing rather than a good one we needed a forward and ended up with a guy who doesnt even know his own age!!!! hope he proves me wrong but doubt it.

U dont rate ballack dam lol and yet u rate duff more

i say the best are tevez and ballack

Well there were quite a few quality players that didnt do much in the WC...Ronaldinho for one.

quote:

Originally posted by CaptVimes:
Well there were quite a few quality players that didnt do much in the WC...Ronaldinho for one.

lol the england team

We got J Low for next to nothing. J Low dances around and sends the audience crazy.

Josh Low, ex-Cardiff player. Even had a p'ss on the side of the pitch while warming up for Wales under-21s v Norway once!

Rossi on loan looks like a good deal.

quote:

Originally posted by Boston Vale:
Rossi on loan looks like a good deal.

Why? A Man United reserve player shipped out to get some experience? Looks an ok deal, but how many goals has he scored for the 1st XI? And how many for the reserves? You'd be better encouraging some of your own reserve strikers to come through and not helping to groom the stars of the future for another club

Best Shevchenko
Worst Carrick (considering the money no way is he worth anywhere near that amount- Bayern bought Van Bommel for £4 million )

quote:

Originally posted by zeds:
Best Shevchenko
Worst Carrick (considering the money no way is he worth anywhere near that amount- Bayern bought Van Bommel for £4 million )

Sorry can I change my worst to Villareal's new signing at centre half Pascal Cygan for £2mil

Best - Shevchencko

Worst - Got to be Charlton buying Traore for 2Mil. lol