Logo, click to go to Fantasy Football site
    C4 Forums    Sport    Fantasy Football    Offside Question
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
One Silver Star
Posted
Consider the following situation.

Andrew and Allen are strikers on the same team, Brown is a defender and Barnaby the goalie.

At a moment in time, Andrew makes an attempt on goal. Brown and Barnaby are between Andrews and the goal. Allen is closer to the goalline than Brown is, further from the goalline than Barnaby, but five metres or so off to the left. He's clearly "in an offside position" but arguably he is not interfering in play and nor is he in a position to take advantage of this offside position.

While the ball is in flight, Brown moves backwards toward the goal to intercept it. (He is now closer to the goalline than Allen is.) He defends with a leaping header, and the ball ricochets off to the left. It lands happily in front of Allen, who then strikes the ball, effecting a goal.

Question: Should Allen be ruled offside and hence the goal disallowed? For the purpose of Andrew's goal attempt, Allen's position was irrelevant. He gained no advantage from being offside. His subsequent goal was caused by being presented the ball by Brown's defensive header.

What do you reckon?
 
Posts: 3395Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
Tsk much easier with salt n pepper pots etc but...
I do believe Brown played Allen onside, therefore the goal stands?
But hey, I guess ultimately it depends on which Ref and officials were there on the day!
As they all seem to change their minds from one game to the next... Big Grin


Devil *14th April 1999 Villa Park* Devil
 
Posts: 616Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Gold Stars
Picture of dyla
Posted Hide Post
yeah, i agree!

refs discretion!


............................................................................................................

Why do we press harder on a remote control when we know the batteries are getting weak?
 
Posts: 1750Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
There was a striker taking out the keeper who was deemed inactive as he took the keepr out from behind, therefore was not in the keeper's sight of vision, therefore inactive.

Call for the 4th official who may or may not have been watching the big screen before calling the ref over to tell him what he saw with his own eyes, but definitely not on a TV replay


************************************************************************

I'm Kairdiff born and Kairdiff bred, and when I dies, I'll be Kairdiff dead
 
Posts: 7148Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Platinum Star
Posted Hide Post
From a fans perspective. If its my team its on side, anyone else its offside...simple really Big Grin


----------------------------------------------------
Touched by his noodly appendage - RAmen.
 
Posts: 25088Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Gold Stars
Posted Hide Post
If the flag goes up then its offside otherwise its not lol
 
Posts: 1224Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
Was the ground mentioned? If it was Man. United/Chelsea/Liverpool/Arsenal at home, who knows if any flag would go up Wink Big Grin


************************************************************************

I'm Kairdiff born and Kairdiff bred, and when I dies, I'll be Kairdiff dead
 
Posts: 7148Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Posted Hide Post
i dont fully understand offside rule and since the refs dont always get it right i have no intention of learning it
 
Posts: 2696Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  
 

    C4 Forums    Sport    Fantasy Football    Offside Question