personally 4 me it was the 2nd 1 bt wht was yours??

There was good in BOTH!! The following examples apply:

Talent (looks):-
Series 1 - Fi Fi
Series 2 - Lily

Entertainment:-
Series 1 - Emperor
Series 2 - Chris

Laughability:-
Series 1 - Erm.... ???? Didn't laugh at any of them
Series 2 - Chav boy (Sammi)

Talent (musician):-
Series 1 - Dudley (though they were a tight unit in the end!)
Series 2 - Samanie (though I liked Chris' song that he played to Gene - that should seriously be recorded. It sounded as if it had potential!)

Better song was in Series 1. IMHO.

Overall entertainment from both series 1 & 2:-
The Demon himself - GENE SIMMONS! OH YEAH!

They were two very different shows, it's difficult to decipher between them.