What is your theory on this?

It seems strange to me

I thought Calvin could have done it at first

but now it's more likely to be OB.

well it does put ob in the frame more but maybe he saw her before they did and did a runner but he got caught on film

Hmm maybe
but he denies being anywhere near the place

Maybe he saw who did it. got freaked out by who it was and ran off

I don't think it was O.B

quote:

Originally posted by Elizabeth-the-third:
I don't think it was O.B

Neither do I but you have to admit it is a bit suspicious, I mean Clare gets pushed, the McQueens are filming and he's there trying to sneak out of The Loft.. hm..

For some reason I really don't think it was him. Not sure why. But revealing who did it in the ep directly after she was pushed seems rather silly to me.

tbh everyone will be in the frame at one point

i think it is too early to let us know who the pusher was yet as well - their doing it to mess with our heads lol and doubt our own opinions i think

Its obviously not him....cos if we supposed to find out who did it at a time when we're all bored of the story its been going on so long it would have just been like well....we could tell that from the star

ye but i think it would mae it to obvious

*make soz

Firstly I can't imagine it being either OB or Max. If they want Tom back, surely it would be better NOT to kill Clare? Social Services aren't gonna give him back unless Clare admits to the whole thing with Tom. Also they wouldn't risk getting found to be a murderer, because then they wouldn't see Tom again anyway.
And I can't imagine Calvin would do it. Not after being law-abiding to the point of arresting his brother. He just seems to good.
I reckon Warren would make a better job of it, and bully her a bit beforehand.
So that leaves Louise, she has been a bit crazy the past couple of days, and it would be a good story if she pushed Clare but can't even remember it...
How annoying would that be though, someone finally gets one over on Clare, and can't remember doing the honours =p

wen claire wakes form her coma es there n shouts at her then es arrested for murder

i thought it was a bid snidy of ob saying he was at home all night, but never saw max, insinuating max was out all night and therefore, could have been him. when max was in most of the evening and ob was the one out. some mate

Yeah but he couldn't say Max was in as he didn't know- imagine if OB said he was in and then Max explained he went to drive and buy or something that would make OB look guilty

Little Pam sorry but i don't agree with your theory and this is why -

It just seems a bit suss that OB asks Tony to delete the evidence on Jacquis mobile as not to implicate him? maybe hes deperate to get rid of the evidence? Also OB said to clare "it will happen on a ordinary night when you least expect it" sounds like he already had a plan in place.

secondly Calvin saw what happened and he didn't rush back to help, surely if he was as good a citizen or police officer as you claim he is he would be first on the sceane to help. unless of course he's guilty and why is his fone at the "drop" sceane?

Warren doesn't need to bully louise beforehand hes been doing it for months anyway so a quick shove would finish the job.

sorry but everyone is in the frame and if anything the least eveidence points to louise.

Its gunna be sum 1 reali unexpected and then were all gunna be like oh my god lol You watch it not even be any of the people we think it is

Ahh didn't get to watch E4 on Friday, waiting for tomorrow on C4 to see the aftermath! OB does seem pretty suspicious then... although I honestly didn't think he would be that stupid to try to kill her.

Someone has already pointed out on here that Calvin's phone was in his back pocket - maybe he saw Clare before the McQueens, bent down (phone drops out of pocket) & thought "Oh well". I just don't think he would go out with the intention of killing her.

In my opinion, Warren and Louise are the only two who would go out to kill her.

Anyway, who knows? Until we're told for sure we're all gonna be coming up with ideas of who it was.

exactly my thought at first but i saw it again and as claire has just hit the ground the phone is already there made my explanation look stupid but i was thinkin leo as he wasnt at home wen calvin went in and that seems strange 2 me

I don't think OB did it, I think he scared himself when he held her against the wall at the Loft so he left.
I think the phone thing makes it all a bit suspicious, I mean Calvin is one of the nice ones. But I totally wouldn't blame him for pushing Clare, she has after all just ruined his whole relationship with Louise.

i reck its more than likley gnna be OB because claire has done so much to OB, max n tom.

i dont think that it is ob.
because they wouldnt give it away so easily would they ?