Hello, what are your thoughts about this episode I don't think it was as good as the last one, but was still good.

Do you think Claire comes back or do you think she is gone for good?

Do you think Jack knows That Aaron is his nephew, when he was arguing with Kate in the FF he said 'You're not even related to him' it made me think he was saying.. you're not but I am. Also Hurley said to Jack, Charlie had told him he shouldn't be raising him and in Claires FB episode in season 1 the psychic guy told her the baby would be in danger if it was raised by anyone else.

I'm cr@p at theories and observations so would be interested to hear what ideas other people have.

Oh, and I still don't like Juliet!!

Overall a pretty poor episode, then again jacks flashback/forwards are always pretty dull. Not alot to report from this episode really which is a shame because of how good epi 9 was. I think you are right about jack knowing he is related to Aaron though.

Hi Wow i actually thought this was one of the best episodes of series 4.. but maybe thats because im a HUGE jack fan and got to see a lot of him Hahah!

Anyway yeah i do agree that jack probably knows because i got the same idea aswell when he said "your not even related to him"

Also what on earth happened with claire ?! Random or what lol but hey this is lost i suppose! Just to clarify the man who was supposedly her dad holding aaran was christian shepherd right.. coz i didnt recognise him at first and had to watch it again.. he looked very different :l

Omggg and is Danielle/Rouseau dead for sure then ??? If she is i am not going to be happy !!!! :@

load of pants if you ask me. Only high point was seeing Christian, the rest was a let down consdiering E09 gave us some real revelations.

Bit peeved TBH, especially as this season has been cust short. Would have hoped for more quality as the season wound-down

lol yeah it was mr shepherd...and im not a jack fan so maybe thats why i didnt really like this epi

Bit dissappointed after last weeks beast of an episode, it only left me thinking about a few things:

1. What was Kate doing for Sawyer? was it something to do with his daughter?

2. I hope Hurley doesnt go crazy, i want him to get back to the island

3. Cant believe Danielle is dead, what a crap way for her to go after surviving 16 years on the island.

Ohhhh nooo she is deaddd Thats so unfair ! I hope we still get to find out about her because if we dont that would be sooo stupid !!!

Another point i noticed is that you know in jacks FF when hes looking at the x-rays then hears the beeping on the fire alarm and walks to go and check it out.. was it just me or did that realllly remind you of the hatch ? Just like the layout of the room and the beeping sounded like the alarm for the numbers going off..

Well, twasnt as good as Ep 9, but to be fair it would have taken a lot to beat that!

The FF was slightly boring tbh, but in Ep 9 the FF wasnt that fandabydozy either, but was definitely made up for with the on-island action. This one did not unfortunately.

Felt very sorry for Hurley, and also very sorry for Jack in the FF, neither are happy at all. I wonder how much is just a self fulfilling prophecy, and how much isnt???

The whole Claire/Christian thing is just bizarre, dont get it at all. Why would Claire or Christian leave Aaron like that?

Well, the interesting bits.....

Charlotte speaks Korean eh? She is a proper clever dick! I think that scene with Jin kinda proved that he was still alive on the island, which is definitely a good thing.

We see the beginning of Jacks dring/drugs problem. Well, maybe not the total beginning, as that probably started in childhood, but anyways that would just start off an extremely long post!!

Danielle looks to be dead. Not good, I really thought she wasnt

Definitely no moments this week.

Yeah it's sad about Danielle, how awful to go like that. Why do they keep bumping off the interesting characters?

I think Kate is contacting Sawyer's daughter, and I think Jack was having trust issues with her - I can't blame him though cos i wouldn't trust kate.

What's confusing is who is alive and who is dead. It's interesting Hurley thinks they're dead - what about Christian popping up in both jack's and Claire's scenes?

Must admit it was nice to see jack and kate together for the brief moment, they were genuinely happy. But you know it's not gonna last...

if miles comes back to the beach they can find out the paoulo and nikki are paralysed. i thought it was an good episode i like when miles referred to sawyer as claire big brother. the miles, sawyer and claire part of the episode aswell as the jin and charlotte and hurley in santa rosa were definetly the best bits of the epi. jorge garcia AKA Huley played mental hurley awesomely that 1 tear was classic. Christian Sheperd i think miles is the key to jack and claire finding out their related which would be kool. if aaron isn't supposed to be raised by another than what is kate doing it doesn't make sense. Kate can raise him but not jack or does the propehercie mean by an othere.g. ben, juliette etc.

I really liked it
Thought it was great.

Very intreseting Hurley-wise.
And I loved the bit where Jin confronted Charlotte.

^ Hi!

That was indeed a good bit, I had forgotten about that. Jin was cool

hi... i thought it was an awesome episode. i too thought that kate was visiting sawyers daughter. i dont think jack knows aaron is his nephew tho. cause why would it take him so long to visit aaron? surely he would want to be a part of his life. i dont see how charlotte speaking korean is significant tho. but oooh how good is jins english coming on!!! and the christian thing!!! i always said that he was jacob. now im more sure than ever. just they way he seems to have control. i mean claire hated him so why would she go with him? and leave aaron?

anyone else think its really nice how protective sawyer is of claire?

Uhh Episode 10 is a Jack episode? Gross.

Although it wasn't a really excited episode, I think it's going to lead up to a really good one either next week or the week after.

I am starting to think that Christian Shepherd has something to do with Dharma. I really want to find out the answer to why he wasn't in the coffin.

I am a Jack fan and am hoping that everything works out for him and that we will see if he does get off the drugs/alcohol and that him and Kate will get married.

I don't know if this has been mentioned before - I haven't been on here in ages, but was it Michael's coffin in the flash forward at the end of season 3, because his new surname is Johnson and wasn't that what it looked like in the newspaper article?

we dont know who is in the coffin yet?

quote:

Originally posted by Jack Sheppard:
we dont know who is in the coffin yet?

Still think it is BEN

i dont usually like jack episodes but i didnt think that this one was too bad. im soooo in love with sawyer though with how hes looking out for claire! where has she gone?? also, weren't the soldiers that were with the pilot attcked last week by the smoke monster???

Claire goes missing? Sawyer continues to be perfect? I DON'T WANT TO WAIT 6 MORE DAYS

Oh Oh Great I just figured out I have a Jack episode on my birthday. Wonderful. Fantastic. Thanks Alot. I Hate You Producers.

haha awwwww......
when's your birthday???

Sunday

Ahhhhhh I just read that Jack and Kate get engaged this episode in a FF is this a Joke? No. Really? Is this some sick twisted prank, to piss of Skate shippers who are an obvious majority over Jate shippers even though the bloody producers are clearly blind and cant seem to see this. Omg this all happens on my birthday. I'm so, not even watching this. I'm just going to kill myself.

Unbelivable.

Lizzie you do make me giggle

Yup, tis true that Jack and Kate get engaged, but the FF is before the FF from Through the looking glass.

now, pour yourself a stiff drink, get a big bar of dairy milk, and enjoy your birthday

Pressie from Smokey