quote:

Originally posted by i-am_lost:
Hey guys, i'm not sure if this has been discussed but the theory that hurley is imagining charlie in the hospital, i was rewatching it and another guy in the hospital came over to him and told him charlie was there so he could obviously see him so it can't just have been in hurleys mind. As i say im not sure if this has been discussed but i thought id see what you guys thought.

Hi i-am-lost, i think someone did mention it...somewhere. But i was wondering was it the same patient that told him Charlie was there, that also told him that the wierd guy from Oceanic wanted to see him....just a thought....

^^Yus I wrote something about this somewhere too. Some lame theory about mad people finding it easier to see ghosts if I remember rightly!! must have been on the fermented apple juice!!

Maybe he was a long lost realitive to Claire's psyhcic

I still think Charlie may have been another manifestation of the black smoke monster....like the lawyer guy.

Ben always said he discovered what the people he wanted to manipulate were most invested in and then exploited it - Hurley can therefore be manipulated by guilt, morals and love for either Charlie or Libby.....- not sure whether i is Ben pulling the strings this time but I reckon it's along the same lines.


I thought the eye was from a younger person at first too; then I thought it was Charlie - after watching it a second time I just don't know what to think.

Great return episode, although it flew by quite quickly.

I try to remember that the show technically isn't dealing with the supernatural, as eveything can apparantely be explained scientifically (so say the creators).