i read that the otheres could be the good ones?
and probaly the losties could be the badies.

i dont kno i just read that.

shannon= Ana Lucia killed her BECAUSE she was trying to shot the others she heard
ana lucia+libby= *michal was told by THE OTHERS to go get henry gale and ana lucia was in the way so he killed her and libby saw that he killed ana so he killed her too*

But i still belive in some way the others are the good guys

i got the impression the "others" have gotten tied up in the whole dharma project thing. in the last episode that video said about the second group being there to watch the people in the hatch and log them (u know what i mean?) I reckon thats the "others". but they cottoned on to the fact that its a mind game.

Yes, Ethan (an other) kidnaps Claire and her baby and kills Scott and tries to kill Charlie and knocks jack out. He is good!
Plus they took walt from his (extremley worried) father and kidnapped kids and many other people, and whilst they havent harmed them, if they were good why not just take them simply and not kidnap them at night and seperate children from parents etc.

Plus Zeke and co shot and tried to kill Mike, Jin and sawyer and also ruined any chances of them leaving the island. Why not let them escape then they could be at peace and everyone wins.

what the person above me said how can they be good but its already tryin to tel us that they are different others aint they

Yes the others could be the good ones,i think they do not leave the island so that they can keep pushing thier own button for dharma. Now Henry Gale has lost his hope because the button was not pushed and he found out nothing happened.

Depends what they mean by 'good'
Whatever they mean, it doesn't rule out total hypocrisy.

Apart from all the kidnappings,
"Stop following me or I'll kill one of them" - Ethan.
Charlie 'killed' - by Ethan.
Scott killed - by Ethan.
Nathan killed - by Goodwin, because otherwise he might have thrown suspiscion on Goodwin, but that's OK because Nathan wasn't a 'good' person'.
All the Tailies who died for lack of help - especially medical attention.
Whatever happened to the real Henry Gale?
Never mind kidnapping Walt - what about Michael, Sawyer and Jin left to die after their raft was blown up?
The fake Henry Gale trying to strangle Ana Lucia - after she saved his life (from Sayid).

In what way are the Others 'good'?

Seriously, how are they 'good'?

i completely agree with hooting heck. They r not good! Poor old Walt- and poor micheal not knowing where his child is and having him say please dad help me help me!!!

The others r EVIL!!!

im sure that the others are involved as they pretty much know ehre some of the hatches are