Logo, click to go to homepage
    C4 Forums    Comedy    Green Wing    Controversial Maybe...
Page 1 2 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Two Gold Stars
Posted
But I really dont think a third series would be a good thing . As much as I love Green Wing we must be aware that the genius of it is it's unpredictability and if it goes on too long it will become very predictable indeed.
They make hour long shows and that is a lot of material to be original with isnt it?
I just think of classics such as Fawty Towers and remember that shows that go out on top are the best kind. Lets hope the writers dont fall into the trap of many American sitcoms and kill Green Wing slowly and painfully.
To sumerise as long as the episode to be shown at Xmas will be wacky ,original and unpredictable I will be a very happy bunny Big Grin


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The older the wine the gooder the wine.
 
Posts: 8302Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of xxGreenWingerxx
Posted Hide Post
i agree jemma! It hasn't got the scope to carry on like only fools and horses or something, It's good enough to end where it is, as much as I'd love a series 3 , I don't think it would work.


------------------------------------

“Come on guys… You know we don’t play British Bulldog in theatre, yeah? If you want to mess around, b*gger off back
to A and E.”

Do I look like a mug? Do I have a handle? Am I made of china? Am I kept in a cupboard or on a small wooden tree? Would you LIKE to put your lips on my rim? You may answer that question.. the others were rhetorical.



 
Posts: 137Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Picture of hellophoebe
Posted Hide Post
So long as the Xmas episode is appropriate and a fitting ending to a brilliant show, then I suppose that I could live without a third series.


GOOD MUMMY....... jesus!
 
Posts: 326Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Picture of JennyMoo
Posted Hide Post
Well all the best comedies go out after only two series, it's like the 27 club for TV.


"Are you tugging my squirrel?"
 
Posts: 385Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
i dont agree. i think there could be load of possibility for a third series which could be realy funny

some i have had if it ends with caroline getting with mac and they deside to get married

they could have meting the family
caroline sister (identical twin) could have her kiss guy mac seeing getting the wrong idea (Both). they could have some really funny scence with caroline no sure what going on. then gets it. and explains she has a twin and no one believes her. trying to find her sister when she find her tell her sister to stay there. go get the guy and she has gone.

then there her brother and mac family. either two ways with the dad either he walk in on her in her underwear. or she is having a bad day and insults him before she finds out he is mac dad. she try and make it up but each time makes it worse. his mum total loved holly. and dad things sue is great making caroline feel very insecure. then theres the new docter who get on really well with everyone. (exspecally mac). Making caroline feel even worse.

martin meting his dad. the engagment party. the wedding which caroline could be kidnapped by guy or sue. the possibilities are endless. end up over the cliff again


hi
 
Posts: 440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of heroverthere
Posted Hide Post
could be very funny if it turns out that caroline really did steal pigs and keep them at her sisters!! Wink


***********************
Judge me all you want, but keep the verdict to yourself

Whoever said nothing is impossible never tried slamming a revolving door
 
Posts: 885Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Gold Stars
Posted Hide Post
Not controversial...absolutely completely CORRECT on all accounts.

*claps*
 
Posts: 1350Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of Little Shakespeare
Posted Hide Post
i know that people always say this and in a way the british sitcoms are right to end it while they are still loved but i just think this would be too soon for GW. you see if you've got a winning formula why not use it? as long as it's still good they can keep it going! i tink that two seasons just isn't enough for this great show!


And In The End The Love You Take Is Equal To The Love You Make

- Remember that, the Beatles were all about love, it's all you need. Peace and love everyone!


Valentine The Beatles - *In My Life I'll Love You More* Valentine
 
Posts: 4631Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of SpooonOfDestiny
Posted Hide Post
the thingabout GW is that it's sketchy, and therefore doesnt have too many characters. The second series became more plot orientated, and the sketches had to spawn from the plot, and therefore they were not as random as the first series-dotn get me wrong s2 was great. But I think a full length s3 wouldnt work as well. Some threads have suggested introducing new characters etc, but would that really work in a show tht is based aroud central characters? There would have to be the intro of the new characters, and thus take away from the sketch style of the show further. The reason I think maybe friends, and other amaerican shows hang on for so long is because they dont set out to nbe sketchy, and also maybe because they all work some where different etc so there is more scope to add extra tihngs in e.g "oh you know so and so from work", where as in GW they all owrk together, live together(guy caro), so you know that that's pretty much all they do. And also the whole pogram has really been centred around who caro will end up with in the end, so when tht's decided, it wld be dragging it out-feel free to shout at me lol!
I know its been mentioned, but Fawlty Towers anyone?!
I'm defo on the ship of going out with a big bang!

sorry was a bit long....couldnt sleep! lol


*What can I tell you? A few ground rules. No bombing, no running, no petting, no diving and no inflatables. In fact, probably best to leave all swimming related activities until later, this is after all an operating theatre*
 
Posts: 204Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
I agree as even though I can see a third series working I still think it would not be as good as the first two. Similarly if the Xmas special is as brilliant the first two series, were all the ends are tied up we would not need another series. Also I feel that it would be better for Green wing to end on a high and not let a third series ruin it. Hence, then we can always remember it for being good and not selling out, as we do with Fawlty Towers and the office. Smile
 
Posts: 485Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
i love the office and i think it is brilllant the way he did one last episode and tide up loose end and he gave the public what they wanted. i hate it when show finish but leave lots of loose end


hi
 
Posts: 440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Gold Stars
Posted Hide Post
Green Wing will tie everything that needs to be tied up, up.

The Christmas super-ep will be the last and it will be spectacular.
 
Posts: 1350Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of Tiny Bird Woman
Posted Hide Post
whilst i would dearly love gw to go on forever, i agree that a 3rd series could only go downhill and that as long as i get the dvd of series 2 and the xmas episode (they are said to be releasing it later) then i will be fine!
however, if the xmas episode ends up with anyone hanging over that bl**dy cliff, i may have to burn down the channel 4 offices!!


------------------------------
"I don't let the squirrel out for just anybody."
"I may be many things, but not being indiscreet isn't one of them."
 
Posts: 187Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of skeadugenga
Posted Hide Post
quote:
if the xmas episode ends up with anyone hanging over that bl**dy cliff, i may have to burn down the channel 4 offices!!


I'm with you there Tiny Bird Woman! It will be flaming torches a go-go


"I know I'm not wearing much makeup, but thats quite rude"
 
Posts: 884Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
everyone have your pitch forks at the ready


hi
 
Posts: 440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
'i love the office and i think it is brilllant the way he did one last episode and tide up loose end and he gave the public what they wanted. i hate it when show finish but leave lots of loose end'

I loved the xmas episode of the office - Tim and dawn finally got together (here's hoping 4 mac and caro), david seemed sort of happy for real this time and like you said gave the public what they wanted. I really hope the green wing writers do the same, but just in case I wil be purchasing a pitch fork before the episode is on.
 
Posts: 485Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Little Shakespeare:
i know that people always say this and in a way the british sitcoms are right to end it while they are still loved but i just think this would be too soon for GW. you see if you've got a winning formula why not use it? as long as it's still good they can keep it going! i tink that two seasons just isn't enough for this great show!


I'm with you Little Shakespeare, I think there is still a lot of quality material to be had. Maybe not past a 3rd series, but it would depend how season 3 ended.
 
Posts: 94Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Posted Hide Post
quote:
I loved the xmas episode of the office - Tim and dawn finally got together (here's hoping 4 mac and caro), david seemed sort of happy for real this time and like you said gave the public what they wanted. I really hope the green wing writers do the same, but just in case I wil be purchasing a pitch fork before the episode is on.


omg i LOVED that episode! i was crying so much with such happiness!!! i agree that as long as the final ep is good i will accept that GW is over and try and get over it!


________________________

"You can either do it my way, or you can be wrong"

SUE WHITE = GOD
Cousin to Heeby and Crossy
Daughter of JOHNOR
Creator of GLUE!
#3 Razzer Razz
 
Posts: 3889Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of Little Shakespeare
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by rustyplatter:
quote:
Originally posted by Little Shakespeare:
i know that people always say this and in a way the british sitcoms are right to end it while they are still loved but i just think this would be too soon for GW. you see if you've got a winning formula why not use it? as long as it's still good they can keep it going! i tink that two seasons just isn't enough for this great show!


yeah exactly. christ if little britain can squeeze out a third series surely green wing can!

I'm with you Little Shakespeare, I think there is still a lot of quality material to be had. Maybe not past a 3rd series, but it would depend how season 3 ended.


And In The End The Love You Take Is Equal To The Love You Make

- Remember that, the Beatles were all about love, it's all you need. Peace and love everyone!


Valentine The Beatles - *In My Life I'll Love You More* Valentine
 
Posts: 4631Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Mel21:
quote:
I loved the xmas episode of the office - Tim and dawn finally got together (here's hoping 4 mac and caro), david seemed sort of happy for real this time and like you said gave the public what they wanted. I really hope the green wing writers do the same, but just in case I wil be purchasing a pitch fork before the episode is on.


omg i LOVED that episode! i was crying so much with such happiness!!! i agree that as long as the final ep is good i will accept that GW is over and try and get over it!
Me too! Nuff said.
 
Posts: 151Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
New Member
Picture of Delicia Malsvir
Posted Hide Post
I think a 3rd series would be amazing, but i have to say i dont think they would be able to follow on from this series with anythnig as good. It just seems that series two is too dramatic and i would be astounded if there was a series 3 that was good enough to follow series 2, that would be worth praising but i dont think its possible. (it saddens me to say this Frown i love green wing and all good things come in three's)


~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~
*You are going to be fine, Just lose some weight*
*I wanted to see what I could have had if I had been a bit more… Ginger*
*would anyone like some... Ham?*
 
Posts: 9Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of skeadugenga
Posted Hide Post
Well we'll all find out on December 25th at 8.30 if the JRT website is to be believed (and I think it is)


"I know I'm not wearing much makeup, but thats quite rude"
 
Posts: 884Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
what's it say on the JRT website?


------------------------------
the English have an amazing ability to turn wine into water.
 
Posts: 384Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of skeadugenga
Posted Hide Post
Just date and time of transmission of the Christmas special - 8.30 on Christmas night.


"I know I'm not wearing much makeup, but thats quite rude"
 
Posts: 884Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post