Culture logo, Click to Return to Homepage
    C4 Forums    Culture    Culture    Would you worship god without the threat?
Page 1 2 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Heselbine
Posted
OK, here's a question for all you christians out there.

Suppose that god existed (should be on solid ground for you so far) but that if you didn't worship him he didn't really mind.

So worshippers go to heaven and worship. Non-worshippers just go to a sort of nice club where you can chill out, drink beer and socialise.

Would you still worship him?


- Proud to be 50% banana -
 
Posts: 2482Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Heselbine:
OK, here's a question for all you christians out there.

Suppose that god existed (should be on solid ground for you so far) but that if you didn't worship him he didn't really mind.

So worshippers go to heaven and worship. Non-worshippers just go to a sort of nice club where you can chill out, drink beer and socialise.

Would you still worship him?


Yes.
 
Posts: 923Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Heselbine
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Mr Woolf:

Yes.


Thank you for humouring me. Why?


- Proud to be 50% banana -
 
Posts: 2482Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Heselbine:
quote:
Originally posted by Mr Woolf:

Yes.


Thank you for humouring me. Why?


Because what He did was pretty praiseworthy, don't you think?
If you watch an artist painting a landscape, you would probably compliment him upon his skills? If he gave you the painting, you would probably tell all of your visitors who admired it what a great guy the artist was. And next time you met him, you would thank him again for his generous gesture, no?
Well, just imagine that someone gave you everything which you owned, plus everything which you would ever need to live a comfortable, happy and fulfilled life.
How highly would you praise Him?
 
Posts: 923Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
New Member
Posted Hide Post
What if you were born in a war zone or some African dictatorship and all your family had just starved to death or been executed?

Happy and fulfilled life?
 
Posts: 6Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by stuart_2:
What if you were born in a war zone or some African dictatorship and all your family had just starved to death or been executed?

Happy and fulfilled life?


But that wasn't the question
 
Posts: 923Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of TheCarpenter
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Mr Woolf:
quote:
Originally posted by stuart_2:
What if you were born in a war zone or some African dictatorship and all your family had just starved to death or been executed?

Happy and fulfilled life?


But that wasn't the question


Perhaps, you'd be good enough to humour him? Given it's his first day and everything.

Hello stuart_2 Smile


---------------
"The fact that we live at the bottom of a deep gravity well, on the surface of a gas-covered planet going around a nuclear fireball 90 million miles away and think this to be normal is obviously some indication of how skewed our perspective tends to be" D Adams
 
Posts: 200Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
God doesnt make threats.
 
Posts: 697Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by leafar:
God doesnt make threats.


Which god would that be? I thought that -by default- we were talking about Yahweh, the jealous sadistic psychopath.

regards
 
Posts: 393Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
Oh him? Yes he makes threats. I was talking about the real one.
 
Posts: 697Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of Chairman Al
Posted Hide Post
Does god survive because of organised religion?

What would you believe if you had never heard of religion?


The thoughts of Chairman Al.

If a man takes no thought about what is distant, he will find sorrow near at hand.
 
Posts: 12178Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
Well me personally, without organised religion, like pretty much most people, i assume, i would probably have either never heard of god, or if i had, whatever i might have heard would have been vague. Ive always hated the idea of having to believe in god and having to follow his rules otherwise you go to hell. I happen to believe in god but im certainly not scared of him. And anyway organised religion is manmade. Its faulty, and in most cases largely stupid.
 
Posts: 697Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of greenbelt
Posted Hide Post
An angel walks into town carrying a burning torch in one hand and a pale of water in the other.
A woman rushes out to meet him: "servant of God what are you going to do ?"
"With this torch i will burn down the mansions of heaven. With this pale of water I will douse the fires of hell.Then we will find out who really loves God....."
 
Posts: 586Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of greenbelt
Posted Hide Post
Nobody goes to heaven who doesn't want to go to heaven.
Nobody goes to hell who doesn't want to go to hell.
 
Posts: 586Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of greenbelt
Posted Hide Post
Heselbine - I think you sum up the situation quite well..... except that God would mind a lot...it's just that he/she wouldn't coerce anyone to go to heaven who doesn't want to. Angel
 
Posts: 586Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by greenbelt:
Nobody goes to heaven who doesn't want to go to heaven.
Nobody goes to hell who doesn't want to go to hell.


I wish I'd said that.
 
Posts: 923Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Heselbine
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by greenbelt:
Heselbine - I think you sum up the situation quite well..... except that God would mind a lot...it's just that he/she wouldn't coerce anyone to go to heaven who doesn't want to. Angel


Threatening people with eternal damnation is pretty close to coercion in my book.

(My book isn't the bible by the way).


- Proud to be 50% banana -
 
Posts: 2482Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Gold Star
Picture of greenbelt
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Threatening people with eternal damnation is pretty close to coercion in my book.


Heselbine - yes, this is the traditional incentive used by the church but if you look at the bible there is a clear development from "angry punishing God" through to "forgiving God who offers salvation to everyone". This reflects the gradual development in human consciousness and greater knowledge of God over time.
 
Posts: 586Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Heselbine
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by greenbelt:

Heselbine - yes, this is the traditional incentive used by the church but if you look at the bible there is a clear development from "angry punishing God" through to "forgiving God who offers salvation to everyone". This reflects the gradual development in human consciousness and greater knowledge of God over time.


Do you or do you not believe that non-believers are eternally damned?


- Proud to be 50% banana -
 
Posts: 2482Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Greenjack
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by greenbelt:
quote:
Threatening people with eternal damnation is pretty close to coercion in my book.


Heselbine - yes, this is the traditional incentive used by the church but if you look at the bible there is a clear development from "angry punishing God" through to "forgiving God who offers salvation to everyone". This reflects the gradual development in human consciousness and greater knowledge of God over time.

but this so called forgiving god of the NT didn't stop the traditional methods being employed.


Cheers
GJ
 
Posts: 2404Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Picture of RedJooles
Posted Hide Post
Would you worship 11 blokes, kicking a piece of leather around some grass, getting paid £80,000 per week for doing their dream job?

Many do, even when they badly let them down (as Liverpool have done so far this season for me... but I don't worship them)!! Mad

Do I worship the God who made the Universe and all the wonderful things found within it, who loves me so completely - yep, I sure do!!! Big Grin Cool
 
Posts: 324Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Heselbine
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by RedJooles:

Do I worship the God who made the Universe and all the wonderful things found within it, who loves me so completely - yep, I sure do!!! Big Grin Cool


All very interesting, but doesn't remotely answer the question.


- Proud to be 50% banana -
 
Posts: 2482Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Picture of RedJooles
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Heselbine:
quote:
Originally posted by RedJooles:

Do I worship the God who made the Universe and all the wonderful things found within it, who loves me so completely - yep, I sure do!!! Big Grin Cool


All very interesting, but doesn't remotely answer the question.


I think I did - 'yep, I sure do!!!' It may have gotten lost amongst the many words I posted!
 
Posts: 324Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Picture of RedJooles
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Heselbine:
quote:
Originally posted by RedJooles:

Do I worship the God who made the Universe and all the wonderful things found within it, who loves me so completely - yep, I sure do!!! Big Grin Cool


All very interesting, but doesn't remotely answer the question.


I've never really asked this question of you before, but when you were a Christian, erm; how did you become a Christian - YOUR testimony?
 
Posts: 324Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Gold Stars
Picture of Heselbine
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by RedJooles:

I've never really asked this question of you before, but when you were a Christian, erm; how did you become a Christian - YOUR testimony?


No, I'm not willing to share that. My feeling is that it will be exploited by those wishing to prove a point, i.e. that "I was never a real christian anyway" and frankly I'm not prepared to get into that sort of discussion.


- Proud to be 50% banana -