The final beach party was a wee bit dodgy. First off, if you have siblings on both islands then you're always a winner Ya'll hear wat i'm sayin. (cue forced sadness from twin)

Secondly Nick, James and Char were always going to be together. And Nick's tone when he made the call. It was as if everyone knew that he wasn't going to go to Sharks. He just followed the Hawkies. But can I just write, Good plan, fair game, props to you Nick

It has been reported on several threads that they made their decisions before the beach party and therefore nothing should be taken away from the Tigers. They were the right and proper winners. Okay they may have discussed things before they made their decisions but if Tiger island was that bad they would not ALL have gone along with it.

Why would they still not have chosen it. they only had to endure a night with the tigers

did anyone prefer the sharks

Is it really worth caring about?

VERY good point about the twins, never thought of it like that!

I think they should have had to have voted seperately, in private so their decisions weren't influenced by the others.