Go
New
Find
Notify
Reply
Admin
New PM!
Posted
23-03-07 12:40
I now rate Punter on top due to that amazing run out he did in the recent Ashes from close in fielding.
Ponting
Richards V
Rhodes
Taylor
Symmonds
Yes..there WAS an idiot caveman... Hunter W. Gatherer
Surely Roger Harper and Mark Waugh merit a mention.
To me, Colin Bland and Jonty Rhodes would both come in the top 2...
Erm Derek Randall- best cover point of altime.....
Tapir Liberation Front
quote:
Originally posted by Rob: Erm Derek Randall- best cover point of altime.....
Uuuuhhhhhh, not if Colin Bland was there.
Who is Roger Harper?
The force be with you.
quote:
Originally posted by Delta Force: Who is Roger Harper?
Jesus Christ mate, the game
is played outside SA you know.
check it out
Who is Jesus Christ? is he a fielder too?
The force be with you.
quote:
Originally posted by Delta Force: Who is Jesus Christ? is he a fielder too?
Well you could say he patrols the boundaries of our hearts.
quote:
Originally posted by Comical Smoking Monkey: Well you could say he patrols the boundaries of our hearts.
Oh heck! A God botherer!
The force be with you.
quote:
Originally posted by Delta Force: Oh heck! A God botherer!
No, I'm a Cod botherer. I go to the North Atlantic and poke cod with a stick.
quote:
Originally posted by Comical Smoking Monkey:
quote:
Originally posted by Rob: Erm Derek Randall- best cover point of altime.....
Uuuuhhhhhh, not if Colin Bland was there.
Deffo Randall ... whippet esque, sharp as Gillette.
Bland was a half yard slower.
quote:
Originally posted by Comical Smoking Monkey:
quote:
Originally posted by Delta Force: Who is Jesus Christ? is he a fielder too?
Well you could say he patrols the boundaries of our hearts.
Woooooo, nice.
Cheers vicar.
Sobers
Randall
Bland
Ponting
Botham
-------------------------------------------------------- I say it so it must be so.
quote:
Originally posted by daydreamings: Sobers Randall Bland Ponting Botham
Jonty Rhodes isn't in your top 5?
************************************************* A crust of bread is better than nothing. Nothing is better than true love. By transitive property, therefore, a crust of bread is better than true love.
quote:
Originally posted by viru:
quote:
Originally posted by daydreamings: Sobers Randall Bland Ponting Botham
Jonty Rhodes isn't in your top 5?
Nah, he's a dreamer
Probably should be separate top 5s for slip fielding and fielding.
Greatest Test XI: Hobbs, Hutton, Bradman (c), Ponting, Tendulkar, Sobers, Gilchrist (wk), Hadlee, Muralitharan, Barnes, McGrath Greatest ODI XI: Jayasuriya, Gilchrist (wk), Ponting, Richards (c), Tendulkar, Hussey, Klusener, Wasim Akram, Waqar Younis, Muralitharan, Garner
That I've seen: Randall, Harper, Rhodes, Ponting, Collingwood.
Dad said to me that Viv Richards was a demon aiming at one stump. The best. There were none better than mark Taylor at first slip and to me that IS a fielding position and Jonty was possibly the quickest off the mark next to Symmonds.
Yes..there WAS an idiot caveman... Hunter W. Gatherer
quote:
Originally posted by Mister Robby: That I've seen: Randall, Harper, Rhodes, Ponting, Collingwood.
Who is Collingwood?
The force be with you.
quote:
Originally posted by Delta Force:
quote:
Originally posted by Mister Robby: That I've seen: Randall, Harper, Rhodes, Ponting, Collingwood.
Who is Collingwood?
Thet are an Aussie Rules football Team
Yes..there WAS an idiot caveman... Hunter W. Gatherer
Sure, just give me their addresses.
Eds suck
You replied twice to this thread Tails and still not posted your top 5.!!
Why. I think you would select much the same as mine being an Aussie gal like me.
Yes..there WAS an idiot caveman... Hunter W. Gatherer
This is my second post on this thread. If you can find two previous I'll donate my brain for your oh-so-badly-needed transplant.
Eds suck
You have to break it down by position. For instance, Taylor is possibly the best slips catcher I have seen but a poor fielder generally. Ponting is the best all round fielder I have seen although I have never seen Token field in slips/ gully. Rhodes was highly overrated.
Please Wait. Your request is being processed...