HomeCinemaDVDOn TVVideoFeaturesMovie
RushMaking
MoviesCompetitionsForum
    C4 Forums    Film    General Film    Is it just me...
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
-star Rating Rate It!  Login/Join 
One Silver Star
Picture of archangel01
Posted
Or was C4's latest countdown a bit of a hit-and-miss Confused I mean it was a good programme but it had quite a few goofs;

The Incredibles higher than Indiana Jones?! Not to mention Grease AND the jungle book! Eek

Shrek beating Mary Poppins?!

Biggest surprize was seeing how far Star Wars has fallen - your thoughts, people!


"My father had a profound influence on me. He was a lunatic"
*Meet the new boss...Same as the old boss*
 
Posts: 3801Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of sarara
Posted Hide Post
I agree with you Arch. Mind you I haven't seen The Incredibles but I'm sure it's not as good as Indiana Jones.

I think there were loads that were missing too. The trouble with these lists is that they have too much recent stuff which though good are often not as good as some great classics.

Here's my top ten of films not in the list, in no particular order:

Ring of Bright Water
Emil and the Detectives
Zazie dans le metro
The Court Jester
The 5000 Fingers of Dr T
Lady and the Tramp
The Incredible Journey (original)
Old Yeller
Hans Christian Anderson
The Black Stallion

I can't believe most of these weren't even nominated let alone in the final list.


~~Never trust a man with uneven sideburns~~
 
Posts: 5440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of talk to me
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Ring of Bright Water
Emil and the Detectives
Zazie dans le metro
The Court Jester
The 5000 Fingers of Dr T
Lady and the Tramp
The Incredible Journey (original)
Old Yeller
Hans Christian Anderson
The Black Stallion


they weren't mentioned because familys don't watch them.....i havn't heard of any of them!!!

E.T number 1, i hate E.T its is the crappest film i have ever seen!

shrek is 10 times better than mary poppins and the incredibles kicks indiana jones's ass


Green Wing is the king
 
Posts: 180Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
idiot
 
Posts: 371Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of sarara
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by talk to me:
quote:
Ring of Bright Water
Emil and the Detectives
Zazie dans le metro
The Court Jester
The 5000 Fingers of Dr T
Lady and the Tramp
The Incredible Journey (original)
Old Yeller
Hans Christian Anderson
The Black Stallion


they weren't mentioned because familys don't watch them.....i havn't heard of any of them!!!

E.T number 1, i hate E.T its is the crappest film i have ever seen!

shrek is 10 times better than mary poppins and the incredibles kicks indiana jones's ass


Oh so becuse YOU haven't heard of them they must be rubbish. My nephews and nieces who are all under 13 have heard of all of them and seen most of them with the family.


~~Never trust a man with uneven sideburns~~
 
Posts: 5440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of sarara
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Wicker Man:
idiot


My sentiments exactly. Thanks KS. And happy hols to you btw. Santa


~~Never trust a man with uneven sideburns~~
 
Posts: 5440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
Family films aren't my bag but I would fear an overdose of saccharine watching ET. I haven't seen Zazie Dans Le Metro for years but from what I remember it was a great film. Cinema Paradiso and Wizard Of Oz are my two choices.
 
Posts: 123Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of talk to me
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Oh so becuse YOU haven't heard of them they must be rubbish. My nephews and nieces who are all under 13 have heard of all of them and seen most of them with the family.


did i ever say that they were rubbish?

i said there prob not on there cos not many people have heard of them....at least not where i'm from

ps. wicker man.... just because you dissagree with my opinion doesn't mean you have to throw insults at me. i pitty you if you have to mock another person to regain there own self-esteem. does it make you feel big?
a bit of advise for later life.....grow up!


Green Wing is the king
 
Posts: 180Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of sarara
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by talk to me:
quote:
Oh so becuse YOU haven't heard of them they must be rubbish. My nephews and nieces who are all under 13 have heard of all of them and seen most of them with the family.


did i ever say that they were rubbish?

i said there prob not on there cos not many people have heard of them....at least not where i'm from


OK maybe you didn't say they were rubbish but there was a certain tone in your post. You actually said "they weren't mentioned because familys don't watch them.....i havn't heard of any of them!!!" My reply was fine because you made a sweeping statement. I take it back about you assuming they were rubbish but I stand by the other part that just because you haven't heard of them doesn't mean others haven't either.

To say 'families don't watch them' is ridiculous. Many families have heard of most of them, though you and yours may not have. Had you heard of most of the older films in the final list? Did you know about 'The Red Ballon', 'A Shot In The Dark', 'Summer Holiday', and countless others made before 1970? 'Hans Christian Andersen' was one of the nominations as were some of the others I've mentioned, but didn't make the final 100. And I can't believe that if you have heard of Disney classics like 'Bambi', 'Dumbo' and the 'Jungle Book' (which I assume you have because they were in the list) that you haven't heard of 'Lady and the Tramp' which is also a Disney classic cartoon.

Out of my list the only ones that may be obscure to people under 25 would be 'Emil and the Detectives', 'The 5000 Fingers of Dr T' and Zazie das le metro'.The others get shown on TV frequently.

Learn a bit before passing judgement about things you don't know. Check them out in imdb.com or elsewhere. Maybe even get videos you might even enjoy them.

As a side note, Bart Simpson and Sideshow Bob in the Simpsons are probably named after the main characters in 'The 5000 Fingers of Dr T' thouoght there is some debate about this.


~~Never trust a man with uneven sideburns~~
 
Posts: 5440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Platinum Star
Picture of nobby88
Posted Hide Post
[QUOTE]Originally posted by sarara:
Ring of Bright Water

[QUOTE]

Now that's a family film.


"If I'd never loved, I never would have cried".

Winner of last poster 28/11/06, 22/02/07 & 17/04/07.
 
Posts: 22259Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of archangel01
Posted Hide Post
Ahhh hey people, happy holidays to you all! Christmas was a bit flat but meh no matter - one of these days I'm going to get it right; wreath on the dorr, cheery family - Why is everyone so cynical these days?

E.T is not crap never was never will be!!!


"My father had a profound influence on me. He was a lunatic"
*Meet the new boss...Same as the old boss*
 
Posts: 3801Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Three Silver Stars
Picture of talk to me
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by sarara:
quote:
Originally posted by talk to me:
quote:
Oh so becuse YOU haven't heard of them they must be rubbish. My nephews and nieces who are all under 13 have heard of all of them and seen most of them with the family.


did i ever say that they were rubbish?

i said there prob not on there cos not many people have heard of them....at least not where i'm from


OK maybe you didn't say they were rubbish but there was a certain tone in your post. You actually said "they weren't mentioned because familys don't watch them.....i havn't heard of any of them!!!" My reply was fine because you made a sweeping statement. I take it back about you assuming they were rubbish but I stand by the other part that just because you haven't heard of them doesn't mean others haven't either.

To say 'families don't watch them' is ridiculous. Many families have heard of most of them, though you and yours may not have. Had you heard of most of the older films in the final list? Did you know about 'The Red Ballon', 'A Shot In The Dark', 'Summer Holiday', and countless others made before 1970? 'Hans Christian Andersen' was one of the nominations as were some of the others I've mentioned, but didn't make the final 100. And I can't believe that if you have heard of Disney classics like 'Bambi', 'Dumbo' and the 'Jungle Book' (which I assume you have because they were in the list) that you haven't heard of 'Lady and the Tramp' which is also a Disney classic cartoon.

Out of my list the only ones that may be obscure to people under 25 would be 'Emil and the Detectives', 'The 5000 Fingers of Dr T' and Zazie das le metro'.The others get shown on TV frequently.

Learn a bit before passing judgement about things you don't know. Check them out in imdb.com or elsewhere. Maybe even get videos you might even enjoy them.

As a side note, Bart Simpson and Sideshow Bob in the Simpsons are probably named after the main characters in 'The 5000 Fingers of Dr T' thouoght there is some debate about this.


ok.........i'm not reading all that

i'm right your wrong...face it


Green Wing is the king
 
Posts: 180Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of archangel01
Posted Hide Post
The Incredibles kicks Indiana's ass??? Ha and I suppose your age group was wondering where the Olsen twins were in all of this 'Oh what an injustice' Roll Eyes

Finding Nemo is a lovely film so that deserves a top spot, I'd like to know what happened to;

An American Tail
Annie
My Neighbour Totturo (sp)
The boy who could fly
Finian's Rainbow

Sarara I LOVE the Court Jester
The pellet with the poison's in vessel with the pestle, the chalice from the palace has the brew that is true Big Grin

It's funniest when the guards repeat it with their armour rattling!


"My father had a profound influence on me. He was a lunatic"
*Meet the new boss...Same as the old boss*
 
Posts: 3801Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted Hide Post
quote:
My sentiments exactly. Thanks KS. And happy hols to you btw.


Merry Christmas to you too sarara
 
Posts: 371Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of tabloid_junkie
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by talk to me:
quote:
Ring of Bright Water
Emil and the Detectives
Zazie dans le metro
The Court Jester
The 5000 Fingers of Dr T
Lady and the Tramp
The Incredible Journey (original)
Old Yeller
Hans Christian Anderson
The Black Stallion


they weren't mentioned because familys don't watch them.....i havn't heard of any of them!!!

E.T number 1, i hate E.T its is the crappest film i have ever seen!

shrek is 10 times better than mary poppins and the incredibles kicks indiana jones's ass


ditto everything u just said!!!


ღღ Nina ღღ
Jesus is a honkey!
Very Chansaux de Classé!

You never know where to look when eating a banana! Wink
 
Posts: 3607Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of tabloid_junkie
Posted Hide Post
E.T is not a fave film of mine but i do think Shrek deserved to be where it was.


ღღ Nina ღღ
Jesus is a honkey!
Very Chansaux de Classé!

You never know where to look when eating a banana! Wink
 
Posts: 3607Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Sparkly Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
As I am in my mid-twenties Mary Poppins and Indiana Jones mean more to me than Shrek or the Incredibles ever could. Perhaps this difference in opinion is simply down to our ages.


Forza Milan
Champions of Europe 2007
 
Posts: 18571Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of tabloid_junkie
Posted Hide Post
id probs say ages more than anythin. im 17 and have grown up with disney and the films such as shrek i just thought shrek was so new and funny when it first came out - and still is now and probs will be for a long time!


ღღ Nina ღღ
Jesus is a honkey!
Very Chansaux de Classé!

You never know where to look when eating a banana! Wink
 
Posts: 3607Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Sparkly Gold Star
Posted Hide Post
I thought Shrek was very overrated. Different strokes for different folks I guess.


Forza Milan
Champions of Europe 2007
 
Posts: 18571Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of tabloid_junkie
Posted Hide Post
i guess so - agree to disagree


ღღ Nina ღღ
Jesus is a honkey!
Very Chansaux de Classé!

You never know where to look when eating a banana! Wink
 
Posts: 3607Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Two Silver Stars
Picture of sarara
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by verno:
As I am in my mid-twenties Mary Poppins and Indiana Jones mean more to me than Shrek or the Incredibles ever could. Perhaps this difference in opinion is simply down to our ages.


I don't think it has anything to do with age. I wasn't born when most of the films I mentioned were made neither was Wicker Man or Arch who's 24 or 25 (Can't remember which and I'm not telling you my age) but we still love them.


~~Never trust a man with uneven sideburns~~
 
Posts: 5440Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of archangel01
Posted Hide Post
.........ahem *whispers*....... Ninja I'm 24 and think Indiana Jones is THE greatest cinematic icon of the past twenty years; I mean come on Speilberg created the last diamond-in-the-rough hero - How could anyone not like Indiana....It's the adventurer for men and the romantic chilvarous hero for women...It's a win/win situation people!!!

...Worshipping over so I'll say happy new year Ninja


"My father had a profound influence on me. He was a lunatic"
*Meet the new boss...Same as the old boss*
 
Posts: 3801Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Four Silver Stars
Posted