Welcome to the Science Forum Return to Homepage
    C4 Forums    Science    Science Forum    I am The Elephant Man: A Bodyshock Special
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
  Login/Join 
New Member
Posted
I was shocked and upset to witness the horrendous, alarming cries,then extremely cruel slaughter of a helpless pig on what appeared to be a completely unrelated documentary on Channel 4 last night. I feel it was completely irrelevant to the documentary and was an entirely unnecessary act to even perform.Which then prevented me from watching what I thought was going to be an interesting documentary.
 
Posts: 1Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
New Member
Posted Hide Post
Well, i do understand your point but i think maybe if you had watched the programme your concern about the pig would probably have faded in comparison to the suffering of Huan, the subject of the programme. His condition and incredible bravery and his courageous spirit put perspective on most of our concerns.
He was an amazing man and tho Channel 4 gives these programmes sensational titles, after 5 mins of watching all you care about is the person underneath the disability.
I hope he will recover or at least find a relief from pain and if he has anymore operations, that they will be a success.
The importance of his loving family was shown.
The Chinese operating theatre was not too sophisticated and though the surgeons did a good job, the techniques seemed rather chaotic and the bloodshed was worse than that of the pig. He seemed to come round too quick after the operation: hope to God he had masses of painkillers afterwards though it wasn't mentioned.
I believe in animal rights also and i agree the slaughter of the pig was wrong but I believe this fact was overshadowed by the importance of the programme and Huan's moving story.
May God be with him.
 
Posts: 3Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
One Silver Star
Picture of madkitten 25
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by rhian71:
Well, i do understand your point but i think maybe if you had watched the programme your concern about the pig would probably have faded in comparison to the suffering of Huan, the subject of the programme. His condition and incredible bravery and his courageous spirit put perspective on most of our concerns.
He was an amazing man and tho Channel 4 gives
these programmes sensational titles, after 5 mins of watching all you care about is the person underneath the disability.

I hope he will recover or at least find a relief from pain and if he has anymore operations, that they will be a success.
The importance of his loving family was shown.
The Chinese operating theatre was not too sophisticated and though the surgeons did a good job, the techniques seemed rather chaotic and the bloodshed was worse than that of the pig. He seemed to come round too quick after the operation: hope to God he had masses of painkillers afterwards though it wasn't mentioned.
I believe in animal rights also and i agree the slaughter of the pig was wrong but I believe this fact was overshadowed by the importance of the programme and Huan's moving story.
May God be with him.


Ditto... Its a fact of lfe animals are slaughtered every day like that in china .They dont have the equipment to slaughter animals more humanely like we do .


House mate no 1 to win
 
Posts: 10587Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  
 

    C4 Forums    Science    Science Forum    I am The Elephant Man: A Bodyshock Special